•  Call: (951) 493-6789


Pizza Toppings

America’s Top 10 Pizza Toppings: A Delicious Ranking!

Pizza is one of the most beloved foods in America and for a good reason. With endless combinations of toppings and crusts, there’s a pizza for every palate. That said, you may be wondering what the most popular toppings in the United States are.

In such a case, we will count down America’s top 10 pizza toppings, from classic to controversial.

1. Pepperoni 

It’s no surprise that America’s favorite pizza topping is pepperoni. The snack gets an extra boost of flavor from this cured and spicy sausage. Pepperoni can be found on pizza menus all around the United States, ranging from those with thin crusts to those with deep dish pies. 

2. Mushrooms 

Mushrooms are a common topping choice for pizza eaters who want to give their pie a little bit of an earthier quality. They have a flavor that is earthy and robust, and they go well with a wide variety of toppings, from onions to sausage. In addition to that, they are an excellent method for ‘concealing’ additional servings of vegetables.

3. Onions 

Even though onions aren’t exactly the most eye-catching pizza topping, they remain a popular choice for a good reason. They impart a crisp and savory flavor to any slice, regardless of whether they are caramelized or left raw. In addition, they are adaptable components that can be combined with a wide range of other toppings and fillings.

4. Sausage 

Another meaty favorite, sausage is a popular addition to pizza. This topping adds a hearty, savory flavor to any pie, whether it’s a spicy Italian sausage or a milder breakfast sausage. Plus, it’s a great way to get some extra protein.

5. Bacon 

Everything is better with bacon, and pizza is no exception. This crispy, salty topping adds a rich, smoky flavor. Plus, it’s a great way to indulge in a little guilty pleasure.

6. Extra Cheese 

For cheese lovers, extra cheese is a must-have topping. Whether it’s mozzarella, cheddar, or a blend of cheeses, extra cheese adds a gooey, decadent layer to any pie. Just be prepared for some serious cheese pulls.

7. Green Peppers 

For those looking to add a little crunch to their pizza, green peppers are a popular choice. These crisp, sweet peppers add a fresh, vegetal flavor to your pie. They’re also a great way to add some color to your pizza.

8. Black Olives 

While not everyone is a fan of these briny little fruits, black olives are a popular topping for many pizza lovers. Their salty, slightly bitter flavor pairs well with a variety of other toppings, from mushrooms to sausage.

9. Pineapple 

This controversial topping has sparked many a debate among pizza lovers. While some swear by its sweet, juicy flavor, others find it an abomination. However, love it or hate it, pineapple is still an undeniable choice for many pizza fans.

10. Jalapenos 

For those craving a little heat, jalapenos are a popular pizza topping. These spicy peppers add a fiery kick to any pie. They’re also a great way to add some Tex-Mex flavor to it.


Overall, pizza will always be beloved food across America, and these top 10 toppings are just a few of the many delicious options available. Whether you’re a die-hard pepperoni fan or a pineapple lover, there’s a pizza out there for you. So next time you’re ordering a pie, try one of these popular toppings and see what the fuss is all about.

If you are looking to order the best New York style pizza in Corona, CA, look no further than our delicious selections here at New York Pizza Department. We’re a family owned business, and we spare no expense, bringing ingredients in from all over the world to duplicate the fine dining of New York. Feel free to click on our ‘Online Order’ tab and experience the best flavors and toppings that only New York Pizza Department can offer!